Hacker ApprovedDepartments

Doom by id Software

Hacker Approved

Ranked 2 of 24 first-person shooters by recommenders

A landmark shooter praised for fast, fluid gameplay, smooth performance and a huge modding scene; critics find its plot thin and lacking heart.

A landmark shooter praised for fast, fluid gameplay, smooth performance and a huge modding scene; critics find its plot thin and lacking heart.

126 people gave an opinion

recommend it
102
criticize it
24
approval share
81%
Each figure is one person. RecommendsCriticizes

Recommended in 12 of 13 months

  1. November 2025: recommended
  2. December 2025: recommended
  3. January 2026: recommended
  4. February 2026: recommended
  5. March 2026: recommended
  6. April 2026: recommended
  7. May 2026: recommended
  8. June 2026: recommended
  9. July 2026: recommended
  10. August 2026: recommended
  11. September 2026: recommended
  12. October 2026: recommended
  13. November 2026: not recommended (month in progress)

Why it carries the badge

  • 102 people recommend itNeeds 10 or more, met.
  • 4.3 recommenders for every criticNeeds 2 to 1 or better, met.
  • Recommended in 12 of 13 monthsNeeds 4 or more, met.

The same three rules apply to every product, and the badge can’t be bought. How the badge works

What people say about it

The reasons people give, with the number of comments that give each one. Open a reason to read what they said.

Why people recommend it

Each mark is one comment

  • Culturally significant genre milestone

    “The first Doom was certainly industry defining, but it and its sequels have never been considered the best by anyone”

    Comment from 7 Jul 2026 in “Microsoft Fire IdTech Team at Id Software”

    “Doom has some star power and is instantly recognizable to pretty much anyone, not just video game fans.”

    Comment from 13 Dec 2025 in “Rats Play DOOM”

    “Doom and Quake/2/3 all represented massive technological jumps over their predecessors”

    Comment from 7 Jul 2026 in “Microsoft Fire IdTech Team at Id Software”
  • Fast, flowing, satisfying gameplay

    “The weapons and monsters are perfectly balanced and fair, and there's a ton of extra levels and mods”

    Comment from 27 May 2026 in “Ask HN: What game have you replayed more times than any other?”

    “The latter feels much more artificial and forced, whereas Doom feels like "just playing a game."”

    Comment from 14 Apr 2026 in “The Case Against Gameplay Loops”

    “Doom was special just because it felt right and the rhythm just flowed as you went deeper”

    Comment from 29 Apr 2026 in “A playable DOOM MCP app”
  • Smooth, well-optimized performance

    “I don’t think unreal engine games play and look as well as custom engine games. Like doom or cyberpunk.”

    Comment from 7 Jul 2026 in “Microsoft Fire IdTech Team at Id Software”

    “Doom worked because it was crazy fast and you could have a lot of sprites on the screen at once”

    Comment from 24 Jun 2026 in “John Carmack on the mistakes around Quake that ruined id software”

    “I have also been very impressed by the performance and fluidity of Doom and Doom Eternal.”

    Comment from 8 Jul 2026 in “Microsoft Fire IdTech Team at Id Software”
  • Endless mods, ports and community content

    “The weapons and monsters are perfectly balanced and fair, and there's a ton of extra levels and mods”

    Comment from 27 May 2026 in “Ask HN: What game have you replayed more times than any other?”

    “This is awesome! the amount of devices doom has not been run on shrinks by the day haha”

    Comment from 25 Jan 2026 in “Doom has been ported to an earbud”

    “We've still got Doom (1993) being ported to anything that has a transistor in it”

    Comment from 18 Jun 2026 in “Stop Killing Games fails to secure EU law despite 1.3M signatures”

What people warn about

Each mark is one comment

  • Thin plot, lacks heart

    “Contemporary boomer game franchises like Doom, Quake, Wolfenstein, etc just don't have "heart".”

    Comment from 27 Aug 2026 in “Hollywood's Video Game Era Is Here. Will It Be Any Good?”

    “Cynical content from the 90s and 2000s that lack "heart" like Quake, Doom, and the like”

    Comment from 27 Aug 2026 in “Hollywood's Video Game Era Is Here. Will It Be Any Good?”

    “the Doom games mostly focused on having cool levels, with plot as an afterthought”

    Comment from 12 Oct 2026 in “The Making Of Super Mario 64 – full Giles Goddard interview (2001)”
  • Flaky early multiplayer

    “Downside is that your framerate was capped to the person with the slowest computer”

    Comment from 18 Nov 2025 in “How Quake.exe got its TCP/IP stack”

    “simply froze both computers whenever there was a communication issue”

    Comment from 24 Jun 2026 in “John Carmack on the mistakes around Quake that ruined id software”
  • Weak sound effects handling

    “The music sounds great but stopping the music to play sound effects sounds terrible”

    Comment from 3 Dec 2025 in “DOOM could have had PC Speaker Music”

    “it sounds significantly worse than Wolfenstein 3D's PC speaker sound”

    Comment from 3 Dec 2025 in “DOOM could have had PC Speaker Music”
  • Unrealistic speed, motion sickness

    “I get horribly motion sick playing some games like Half-Life 2, Metroid Prime, or the original DOOM.”

    Comment from 27 Oct 2026 in “New iPad mini”

    “The player speed in Doom is completely unrealistic, which is fun, but plays against immersion.”

    Comment from 24 Dec 2025 in “Quake's Player Speed According to John Romero (2017)”

Other first-person shooters people recommend

The four most recommended other first-person shooters, with the same counts for each, so you can compare like for like. The tick on each bar marks the 2 to 1 line the badge needs.

Doom by id Software compared with 4 alternatives
ProductRecommendCriticizeApprovalMonthsOwnedBadge
Quake1182980%1228 yrs8 ownersApproved
Doom by id SoftwareThis page1022481%12—Approved
Unreal Tournament 2004511281%6—Approved
Quake III Arena49394%10—Approved
Half-Life42786%10—Approved
See all 24 first-person shooters, ranked

What people said

40 of the 133 comments that mention it, newest first. Each links to the original comment.

“I get horribly motion sick playing some games like Half-Life 2, Metroid Prime, or the original DOOM.”

CriticizesComment from 27 Oct 2026 in “New iPad mini”

“the Doom games mostly focused on having cool levels, with plot as an afterthought”

MixedComment from 12 Oct 2026 in “The Making Of Super Mario 64 – full Giles Goddard interview (2001)”

“Contemporary boomer game franchises like Doom, Quake, Wolfenstein, etc just don't have "heart".”

CriticizesComment from 27 Aug 2026 in “Hollywood's Video Game Era Is Here. Will It Be Any Good?”

“Cynical content from the 90s and 2000s that lack "heart" like Quake, Doom, and the like”

CriticizesComment from 27 Aug 2026 in “Hollywood's Video Game Era Is Here. Will It Be Any Good?”

“But damn, did I have fun playing that game... especially multiplayer over a modem.”

RecommendsComment from 31 Jul 2026 in “Half-Life ported to Mac OS 9”

“the Jaguar port of Doom, which was the most faithful adaptation of its generation, written by Carmack himself”

RecommendsComment from 9 Jul 2026 in “How Donkey Kong Toppled Atari”

“The last 2 doom games sold quite well and have a unique look and feel that is associated with idtech.”

RecommendsComment from 8 Jul 2026 in “Microsoft Fire IdTech Team at Id Software”

“I have also been very impressed by the performance and fluidity of Doom and Doom Eternal.”

RecommendsComment from 8 Jul 2026 in “Microsoft Fire IdTech Team at Id Software”

“The first Doom was certainly industry defining, but it and its sequels have never been considered the best by anyone”

MixedComment from 7 Jul 2026 in “Microsoft Fire IdTech Team at Id Software”

“I don’t think unreal engine games play and look as well as custom engine games. Like doom or cyberpunk.”

RecommendsComment from 7 Jul 2026 in “Microsoft Fire IdTech Team at Id Software”

“Doom and Quake/2/3 all represented massive technological jumps over their predecessors”

RecommendsComment from 7 Jul 2026 in “Microsoft Fire IdTech Team at Id Software”

“simply froze both computers whenever there was a communication issue”

MixedComment from 24 Jun 2026 in “John Carmack on the mistakes around Quake that ruined id software”

“Doom worked because it was crazy fast and you could have a lot of sprites on the screen at once”

RecommendsComment from 24 Jun 2026 in “John Carmack on the mistakes around Quake that ruined id software”

“he had great taste in metal. most of the tracks were adapted (now classic) speed/thrash metal.”

RecommendsComment from 20 Jun 2026 in “Bobby Prince, composer for Doom, Wolfenstein 3D, and Duke Nukem 3D, has died”

“We've still got Doom (1993) being ported to anything that has a transistor in it”

MixedComment from 18 Jun 2026 in “Stop Killing Games fails to secure EU law despite 1.3M signatures”

“The weapons and monsters are perfectly balanced and fair, and there's a ton of extra levels and mods”

RecommendsComment from 27 May 2026 in “Ask HN: What game have you replayed more times than any other?”

“the stupid mechanics where crowds of enemies described as intelligent humanoids never surrendered, almost never tried to flee”

CriticizesComment from 27 May 2026 in “The Melancholy of Slaying Monsters”

“there were a few gems that I really enjoyed (Aliens vs Predator, Doom, Wolf 3d, Iron Soldier, and Tempest 2000)”

RecommendsComment from 8 May 2026 in “PC Engine CPU”

“still played and modded, and now a semi-meme benchmark for low-spec hardware”

RecommendsComment from 29 Apr 2026 in “Show HN: Rip.so – a graveyard for dead internet things”

“Doom was special just because it felt right and the rhythm just flowed as you went deeper”

RecommendsComment from 29 Apr 2026 in “A playable DOOM MCP app”

“The latter feels much more artificial and forced, whereas Doom feels like "just playing a game."”

RecommendsComment from 14 Apr 2026 in “The Case Against Gameplay Loops”

“It was butter-smooth at 20 fps if you also had a VLB graphic card.”

RecommendsComment from 10 Apr 2026 in “Intel 486 CPU announced April 10, 1989”

“they nailed a really interesting formula and continued to tweak it in each game”

RecommendsComment from 30 Jan 2026 in “PlayStation 2 Recompilation Project Is Absolutely Incredible”

“"I know! Let's restart the version numbering for no good reason!" becomes DOOM (2016)”

MixedComment from 29 Jan 2026 in “Retiring GPT-4o, GPT-4.1, GPT-4.1 mini, and OpenAI o4-mini in ChatGPT”

“tetris, doom, minecraft will be remembered for centuries/millenia”

RecommendsComment from 26 Jan 2026 in “Video Games as Art”

“This is awesome! the amount of devices doom has not been run on shrinks by the day haha”

RecommendsComment from 25 Jan 2026 in “Doom has been ported to an earbud”

“Great gameplay but the way the monster corpses disappear just upsets me”

MixedComment from 12 Jan 2026 in “Personal thoughts/notes from working on Zootopia 2”

“the original doom and quake kept the corpses around”

MixedComment from 12 Jan 2026 in “Personal thoughts/notes from working on Zootopia 2”

“these old games have become kind of timeless platforms for content (doom too)”

RecommendsComment from 5 Jan 2026 in “Quake Brutalist Jam III”

“Doom offered very nice gentle "bobbing" that added to the illusion of a real person's gait”

RecommendsComment from 25 Dec 2025 in “Quake's Player Speed According to John Romero (2017)”

“The player speed in Doom is completely unrealistic, which is fun, but plays against immersion.”

MixedComment from 24 Dec 2025 in “Quake's Player Speed According to John Romero (2017)”

“praised for being surprisingly well optimized for the graphics they offer”

RecommendsComment from 23 Dec 2025 in “The post-GeForce era: What if Nvidia abandons PC gaming?”

“Doom was a big milestone in video game history and 90s tech culture.”

RecommendsComment from 13 Dec 2025 in “Rats Play DOOM”

“Doom has some star power and is instantly recognizable to pretty much anyone, not just video game fans.”

RecommendsComment from 13 Dec 2025 in “Rats Play DOOM”

“Doom pioneered the FPS genre in the USA. So it has a cultural significance.”

RecommendsComment from 13 Dec 2025 in “Rats Play DOOM”

“it sounds significantly worse than Wolfenstein 3D's PC speaker sound”

CriticizesComment from 3 Dec 2025 in “DOOM could have had PC Speaker Music”

“The music sounds great but stopping the music to play sound effects sounds terrible”

MixedComment from 3 Dec 2025 in “DOOM could have had PC Speaker Music”

“it spawned a myriad of forks and new developments continuing to this day”

RecommendsComment from 20 Nov 2025 in “Microsoft makes Zork open-source”

“Downside is that your framerate was capped to the person with the slowest computer”

MixedComment from 18 Nov 2025 in “How Quake.exe got its TCP/IP stack”

“The final release had a reduced viewport and a bad framerate, but the background music was great”

MixedComment from 18 Nov 2025 in “Rebecca Heineman has died”

Counts come from 1,795,640 Hacker News comments, November 2025 to November 2026. How we count. Report a mistake.