Dock team chat

“such a terrible waste of memory/screen space”

“By having so few features, it's competing with a whole lot of free stuff.”

“This clearly isn’t a Show HN - it’s a waitlist signup.”

“The value prop sounds solid, but on the homepage I really missed seeing the product.”

“To me that type of sleight-of-hand inspires distrust, which is fatal to any prospect of me evaluating the product.”

“the location of your servers is irrelevant if you're a U.S.-based company”

“it just exchanges one US based company for several others”

“You guys are awesome! I hope you will succeed.”

“if i can't self host then you've already locked my data in.”

“We are a Western European company, so GDPR and data sovereignty are at the heart of our architecture”

“we're betting that for many teams, the "social" aspect has actually become too noisy”

“gives you full ownership of your data, instant search (even offline)”

“give those teams a professional-grade experience (unlimited search, speed, reliability) without the enterprise tax or complexity”

“I don’t want to have my data in the US for at least 3 years.”

“I don't hate it, but it's also nothing amazing.”

“IMO this package you’re advertising is kind of a contradiction and/or a no-man’s land.”

“I see nothing mentioned about integrating webhooks or some kind of similar feature”

“This new product doesn't have those things because they haven't had time to build them yet.”

“Odd that your site would show macOS looking window for a product with an identical name to a major feature”

“not doubting it's useful but it feels very vibecoded”

“The chat part, channels, tagging and upload of asset isn't enough”

“reads to me like more the claims of a low cost MVP that hasn't solved those issues yet”

“seeing the repeated phrases and words made me navigate back about 30% through”

“The decisions feature, and the focus on good async”

“I don't trust anything that says "Free Forever" or "Unlimited"”

“if you're going to position yourself as a Slack competitor you have to actually do what Slack does”

“replicating the api is a great idea!”

“we are building a focused, high-performance tool for teams that just want the core communication experience to work perfectly”

“we can afford to treat the free tier as a sustainable on-ramp rather than a loss leader”

“Just another SaaS whose promises we are forced to trust, but have no way of ensuring they keep them.”

“we prioritize a seamless "it just works" experience with standard high-security industry practices”

“it's at odds with the "chat that just works" messaging that suggests an advantage in reliability or UI”

“90 day memory loss is a feature, not a bug.”

“your team-based pricing model is a much better selling point”

“It is a flat fee for the whole team. $15/month covers your entire group (up to 20 people).”

“Buyers may question long-term sustainability or fear undisclosed "shadow" caps.”

“we default to unlimited history (since the 90-day hard limit is a pain for most)”

“if you can nail that management of external users, I think that is important”

“Free forever for teams up to 5. Unlimited search, unlimited history.”

“I wrote a spec to solve this”