bcachefs

“I think bcachefs social problems come in part from its hidden technical deficits.”

“That factor went away with BcacheFS choosing to not get mainlined into Linux Kernel.”

“I switched my pools to it from ZFS last year and it is working swimmingly.”

“it simply needs to have a few more years under its belt before I'll be comfortable with it”

“the current state does not qualify for usage within enterprise environments”

“actual users seem happy and my life is far better”

“which is just way more stable and performant than btrfs”

“it's good enough for me and other users”

“bcachefs just hit a setback, which i am hopeful will eventually be resolved”

“bcachefs on Arch is a bit better supported, we have the distro package maintainer in the bcachefs IRC channel”

“Seeing great results from bcachefs”

“Community's still growing, though. A lot of people have gotten active in making sure bcachefs actually works well for people end to end”

“there is nothing else over there with the same set of features”

“I'm pretty sure Bcachefs is amazing and better than Btrfs.”

“You can mix devices of different sizes and types on bcachefs.”

“mixing different device tiers and having a per-file/directory replication setting is a god send”

“a questionable history of reliability”

“It's relatively easy to get it working as a kernel module at least.”

“the developer has sabotaged the project into being removed from mainline”

“I daily drive bcachefs (it's been great!”

“Given the issues with well-known filesystems like ZFS and BetterFS”

“BcacheFS is really cool and yet another step forward in performance and reliability.”

“bcachefs is slowly working up to what you're describing - describing what you want and letting the filesystem sort it out.”

“there are genuine issues with those”

“Without upstreaming it wouldn't get traction it have now.”

“Upstreaming it in the first place was probably a mistake.”

“I've had both btrfs and bcachefs multidevice filesystems lock up read-only on me.”

“Isn't bcachefs even younger and less polished than btrfs?”

“Does it not also eat data though?”

“reconcile, which puts our data and drive management head and shoulders above other filesystems”

“bcachefs came and… appears to have gone nowhere AFAICT”

“Got it removed from the kernel just in time”

“bcachefs has been doing quite a bit better than other filesystems have /after/ they've dropped the experimental level.”

“the removal from the mainline kernel has seriously undermined its credibility for use within a company environment”

“the reason bcachefs's (and bcache's) btree is so fast is that we use much bigger nodes”

“No erasure coding yet though, so I'm in no rush to migrate my home NAS”

“I do hope that when development slows down and time has passed, you get it upstreamed again.”

“to use the Linux page cache instead of dedicating RAM to ZFS”

“it just can't be trusted at the moment”

“Haven't had any issues on a simple mirrored array, which I've been running since before it was in (and out) of the kernel.”