Xbox One
Ranked 9 of 29 game consoles by recommenders
Known for strong anti-piracy security that held up for years and a long lifespan for owners. Critics point to online requirements and buggy system software updates.
Known for strong anti-piracy security that held up for years and a long lifespan for owners. Critics point to online requirements and buggy system software updates.
66 people gave an opinion
- recommend it
- 21
- criticize it
- 45
- approval share
- 32%
Recommended in 9 of 13 months
- November 2025: recommended
- December 2025: recommended
- January 2026: recommended
- February 2026: not recommended
- March 2026: recommended
- April 2026: not recommended
- May 2026: not recommended
- June 2026: recommended
- July 2026: recommended
- August 2026: recommended
- September 2026: recommended
- October 2026: recommended
- November 2026: not recommended (month in progress)
Owned for 10 years
Median of the 3 owners who said how long they have had it.
Each square is one year.
Why it doesn’t carry the badge
- 21 people recommend itNeeds 10 or more, met.
- 0.4 recommenders for every criticNeeds 2 to 1 or better, not met.
- Recommended in 9 of 13 monthsNeeds 4 or more, met.
The same three rules apply to every product, and the badge can’t be bought. How the badge works
What people say about it
The reasons people give, with the number of comments that give each one. Open a reason to read what they said.
Why people recommend it
Each mark is one comment
Strong security resisted years of hacking
“They kept piracy off the console for its whole lifespan, which was the entire point of these security measures.”
Comment from 17 Mar 2026 in “Microsoft's 'unhackable' Xbox One has been hacked by 'Bliss'” “Microsoft have proven you can build an effectively unbeatable security system for general computing devices”
Comment from 8 Oct 2026 in “AnyPS5: Port PS5 binaries to PC without emulation (87% system libraries mapped)” “it held up against 13 years of dedicated efforts by people with physical access to the device”
Comment from 17 Mar 2026 in “Microsoft's 'unhackable' Xbox One has been hacked by 'Bliss'” - Comment from 3 Jul 2026 in “Physical disc production ending in Jan 2028 for new games on PlayStation”
- Comment from 17 Mar 2026 in “Microsoft's 'unhackable' Xbox One has been hacked by 'Bliss'”
- Comment from 17 Mar 2026 in “Microsoft's 'unhackable' Xbox One has been hacked by 'Bliss'”
Versatile, long-lived console owners kept
“Honestly my Xbox one S might be my favorite console I’ve ever owned. Certainly my most versatile.”
Comment from 13 Dec 2025 in “Sick of smart TVs? Here are your best options” “I've had an XBOX ONE S for a long time”
Comment from 13 Dec 2025 in “Sick of smart TVs? Here are your best options” Good hardware and well-judged design
“I would say they got it all right with the Xbox one.”
Comment from 26 Jun 2026 in “My Steam Machine Is a 50ft HDMI Cable” “it was a good piece of hardware”
Comment from 30 Jan 2026 in “PlayStation 2 Recompilation Project Is Absolutely Incredible”
What people warn about
Each mark is one comment
Slow, buggy system software and updates
“But the system software quality is absolute rubbish.”
Comment from 4 Aug 2026 in “Xbox goes down. You can't play games you own on disc” “literally impossible to play any game without a massive patch, debugging os software issues etc.”
Comment from 13 Nov 2025 in “Valve is about to win the console generation” “turn on the xbox, wait 20-30min for mandatory updates, then need to re-sign in”
Comment from 6 Jul 2026 in “Resetting Xbox” - Comment from 7 Jul 2026 in “Resetting Xbox”
Online check-ins and blocked disc resale
“being online only and blocking the resale/trade of physical disc based games”
Comment from 7 Sep 2026 in “TiVo to charge money for skipping commercials in your own recordings” “Xbox gutted a lot of planned Family Sharing support when Sony claimed the Xbox One was not going to allow you to play games offline”
Comment from 4 Aug 2026 in “Xbox goes down. You can't play games you own on disc” “Xbox One was originally going to require frequent online check ins, I think daily or weekly”
Comment from 22 Oct 2026 in “Xbox wants you to pay 24 to 40 cents per hour to stream games you bought” - Comment from 2 Feb 2026 in “Claude Code is suddenly everywhere inside Microsoft”
Focus drifted away from gaming
“Microsoft decided they wanted to look more like Playstation, focused on gaming”
Comment from 15 Jun 2026 in “Fox to Buy Roku Streaming Service in $22B Deal” “XBox was fine up to the Xbox One -- that's when the XBox was co-oped for some broader push for the living room computing”
Comment from 25 Oct 2026 in “Xbox Turns Down Netflix $500M Offer” “Microsoft was far more focused on broadening the scope of the device beyond games”
Comment from 13 Nov 2025 in “Steam Machine” Confusing model names
“I find myself mixing up the One X, One S, Series X, and Series S”
Comment from 14 Nov 2025 in “Steam Machine” “Xbox One (not to be confused with the original Xbox 1)”
Comment from 29 Jan 2026 in “Retiring GPT-4o, GPT-4.1, GPT-4.1 mini, and OpenAI o4-mini in ChatGPT” “Xbox One was a stupid name, and the current letters are just straight up confusing.”
Comment from 28 Dec 2025 in “2025 was the year Xbox died”
Other game consoles people recommend
The four most recommended other game consoles, with the same counts for each, so you can compare like for like. The tick on each bar marks the 2 to 1 line the badge needs.
| Product | Recommend | Criticize | Approval | Months | Owned | Badge |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Valve Steam Machine | 326 | 240 | 58% | 12 | 1 mo5 owners | — |
| PlayStation 5 | 121 | 181 | 40% | 12 | 3 yrs8 owners | — |
| Xbox console | 62 | 212 | 23% | 12 | 21 yrs6 owners | — |
| Xbox 360 | 41 | 19 | 68% | 12 | — | Approved |
| Xbox OneThis page | 21 | 45 | 32% | 9 | 10 yrs3 owners | — |
What people said
40 of the 75 comments that mention it, newest first. Each links to the original comment.
“XBox was fine up to the Xbox One -- that's when the XBox was co-oped for some broader push for the living room computing”
“the reason I stopped using the PS”
“Xbox One was originally going to require frequent online check ins, I think daily or weekly”
“it wasn't as smooth as it is on a PC to bring up the chat and quickly type commands”
“It has very little in the way of exclusives, and it can run emulators on Dev Mode.”
“Microsoft have proven you can build an effectively unbeatable security system for general computing devices”
“being online only and blocking the resale/trade of physical disc based games”
“for the internet to be online all the time "to validate software licenses"”
“Did they learn nothing from the shit storm that MS set off when they tried this with the Xbox years ago?”
“But the system software quality is absolute rubbish.”
“Xbox gutted a lot of planned Family Sharing support when Sony claimed the Xbox One was not going to allow you to play games offline”
“It's never a seamless experience that you would expect of a game console”
“constant crashes, poor performance, it was just such a constant pain in my ass”
“Xbox is a dedicated gaming device and while the game/device is updating I'll have to sit there.”
“turn on the xbox, wait 20-30min for mandatory updates, then need to re-sign in”
“The Xbox One might be single handledly the most complex and secure piece of human hardware.”
“I would say they got it all right with the Xbox one.”
“showing a new logo while the machine is doing something meaningless to us is an act of brand destruction”
“Every console on the market right now is locked-down proprietary garbage”
“Microsoft decided they wanted to look more like Playstation, focused on gaming”
“fairly trivial countermeasures that could have been used to prevent it”
“They kept piracy off the console for its whole lifespan, which was the entire point of these security measures.”
“They also told everyone they added more anti glitching to later hardware revisions”
“the xbox one is extremely secure, despite not being perfectly secure”
“It wasn't unhackable and decrypted versions of games already have been dumped.”
“It literally got hacked, that's what the article is about. It is NOT unhackable.”
“Xbox One was definitely the most unhackable console of its generation.”
“it held up against 13 years of dedicated efforts by people with physical access to the device”
“the original Xbox One announcement needing a Kinect and persistent internet connection”
“it was a good piece of hardware”
“Xbox One (not to be confused with the original Xbox 1)”
“everyone was calling it the X bone because it had no games and cost a million bux”
“The game experience never improved and the home entertainment thing never materialized”
“Xbox One was a stupid name, and the current letters are just straight up confusing.”
“the name alone was indicative of a rot and disfunction beyond comprehension”
“Honestly my Xbox one S might be my favorite console I’ve ever owned. Certainly my most versatile.”
“I've had an XBOX ONE S for a long time”
“I find myself mixing up the One X, One S, Series X, and Series S”
“Microsoft was far more focused on broadening the scope of the device beyond games”
“literally impossible to play any game without a massive patch, debugging os software issues etc.”
Counts come from 1,795,640 Hacker News comments, November 2025 to November 2026. How we count. Report a mistake.