There Is No Antimemetics Division by qntm

What hackers pick instead

• Project Hail Mary by Andy WeirA fun, hopeful science-driven sci-fi story about friendship, with an acclaimed audiobook and a faithful film adaptation; critics find the plot too convenient and the movie simplified.117recommend
• Blindsight by Peter WattsA dense hard SF first-contact novel recommended for its unsettling exploration of intelligence without consciousness; many find the prose hard to follow and the vampires and plot distracting.96recommend
• Dune by Frank HerbertInfluential science fiction admired for its deep world-building, fresh voice and ideas about power and machines. Critics find it long and dense, and say the later books decline.82recommend
• Accelerando by Charles StrossReaders praise its prescient ideas about digital minds, space travel and the future. Critics most often say the characters feel thin or unlikeable.71recommend
• Hyperion by Dan SimmonsFans praise its ideas, religion and prose as top space opera. Common caveat: it ends on a cliffhanger.66recommend

Every quote

The 40 most detailed of 156 comments. Each links to the original.

1. Outside of the wonderful introductory set-up and the initial inverted set-piece of 'Your first day', there is little for the book to recommend itself as a piece of literature

   Mixed · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

2. The Big Bad Thing has so many manifestations that it feels like monster of the week rather than a true full book that holds onto a core sharply executed identity.

   Mixed · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

3. It's such a page turner that the book has become one of my default recommendations for people looking to get back into reading.

   Recommends · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

4. the introductory short story (this one) brilliant, as it's short, shows a clever and surprising inversion of roles midway

   Mixed · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

5. 2025 paid version has more coherent ending (which is nice) and more linear timeline for your average non-technical Joe.

   Recommends · Feb 2026 · in “MMAcevedo aka Lena by qntm”

6. I didn't think "There Is No Antimemetics Division" did very well with its premise, but the premise is quite fascinating

   Mixed · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

7. It's worth it for the originality. Both the plot and the storytelling format are very weird and very original.

   Recommends · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

8. the book is very one-note, it's like a horror movie that keeps doing the same jumpscare over and over again

   Mixed · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

9. The second half was garbage, but the first half was so good and original I'd recommend it just for that.

   Mixed · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

10. if you like antimemes as a concept then this is a nice treatment that introduces people to what it means

    Recommends · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

11. The rewrite definitely improves on the ending and its delivery, but it's still largely the same plot

    Mixed · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

12. the ideas are so good but then it becomes hard to endure through to whatever resolution was waiting

    Mixed · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

13. Technically, I read "There Is No Antimemetics Division" last year, but I'd already kind of read it

    Mixed · Jan 2026 · in “Sins of the Children (Adrian Tchaikovsky)”

14. It sort of meanders and fizzles out. It starts so strong it seems impossible to finish as strong.

    Mixed · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

15. more than "There is not anti-mimetics division" which I felt lost itself in the second half

    Mixed · Dec 2025 · in “Ask HN: What did you read in 2025?”

16. it all kind of clicks at the end, when we realize we had the rug pulled from under our feet

    Recommends · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

17. It's very stiff and heavy-handed, as if the writer's only goal is to setup the next twist.

    Mixed · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

18. But has that potential but where it lands is closer to monster-of-the-week in book form.

    Mixed · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

19. The core conceit lent itself so well to a (subverted) introductory "As you know" chapter

    Recommends · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

20. the second half got a significant overhaul which fixed almost all of my issues with it

    Recommends · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

21. The book did a commendable job.But I was ready for it to be over when it was over.

    Mixed · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

22. One of the more original titles I've read in recent years that gives that feeling

    Recommends · Mar 2026 · in “Rendezvous with Rama”

23. Still one of the more original bits of sci fi / horror to be published in a while

    Recommends · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

24. Great idea, brilliantly executed. Definitely worth it for the first third alone.

    Mixed · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

25. I thought some of the padding out of earlier parts arguably came out worse.

    Mixed · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

26. It has many interesting ideas and a plot with some truly unexpected twists.

    Recommends · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

27. It reads as a religious person who accidentally wrote a good sci-fi book then hurridly, at the end, reminds us all that its really a parable

    Criticizes · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

28. the "editing pass" was minimal. Names changed and some scenes reworked a tiny bit, but it's the same thing.

    Criticizes · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

29. I don't see a coherent plot so far. But all the chapters seem to have the same gimmick

    Criticizes · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

30. I also didn't think it was quite as good as it was hyped to be, but as someone who has long been into the web-based SCP stuff, I did appreciate how the book is introducing SCP to a wider audience.

    Mixed · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

31. It's an enjoyable read, hopefully it's the start of a whole new arc in the series with more to come.

    Recommends · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

32. Qntm is great and their latest book, There Is No Antimemetics Division, recently was on HN as well

    Recommends · Apr 2026 · in “The Future of Everything Is Lies, I Guess: Culture”

33. I read the original antimemetic division book a few times, and gifted the book to few friends too

    Recommends · Feb 2026 · in “MMAcevedo aka Lena by qntm”

34. I feel like is just looming as a possible and frustratingly shallow justification of the book

    Mixed · Mar 2026 · in “Sci-Fi Short Film "There Is No Antimemetics Division" [video]”

35. it's entirely consistent with the meta-nature of the book, especially the self-conscious part

    Recommends · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

36. trying to cohere the structure of the book with the topic matter which I really appreciate

    Recommends · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

37. but something to appreciate, it allows us to see through the media and into the author

    Recommends · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”

38. I'm a big qntm fan. I highly recommend their "antimemetics" SCP stories and articles.

    Recommends · Dec 2025 · in “Qntm's Power Tower Toy”

39. a great book recently called There Is No Antimemetics Division, to rave reviews on HN

    Recommends · May 2026 · in “Incredible Story of Troy”

40. the general idea is much better than just verbally stating it is hard to remember

    Mixed · Apr 2026 · in “Book Review: There Is No Antimemetics Division”