Hacker ApprovedDepartments

Apple iPod

Hacker Approved

The most recommended of 11 portable music players

Loved for its click wheel and simple, polished offline interface, with old units still working years later; critics cite clunky iTunes-dependent syncing and glitchy, unreliable hard drives.

Loved for its click wheel and simple, polished offline interface, with old units still working years later; critics cite clunky iTunes-dependent syncing and glitchy, unreliable hard drives.

134 people gave an opinion

recommend it
102
criticize it
32
approval share
76%
Each figure is one person. RecommendsCriticizes

Recommended in 12 of 13 months

  1. November 2025: recommended
  2. December 2025: recommended
  3. January 2026: recommended
  4. February 2026: recommended
  5. March 2026: recommended
  6. April 2026: recommended
  7. May 2026: recommended
  8. June 2026: recommended
  9. July 2026: recommended
  10. August 2026: recommended
  11. September 2026: recommended
  12. October 2026: recommended
  13. November 2026: not recommended (month in progress)

Owned for 6 years

Median of the 6 owners who said how long they have had it.

Each square is one year.

Why it carries the badge

  • 102 people recommend itNeeds 10 or more, met.
  • 3.2 recommenders for every criticNeeds 2 to 1 or better, met.
  • Recommended in 12 of 13 monthsNeeds 4 or more, met.

The same three rules apply to every product, and the badge can’t be bought. How the badge works

What people say about it

The reasons people give, with the number of comments that give each one. Open a reason to read what they said.

Why people recommend it

Each mark is one comment

  • Polished, simple interface

    “You cannot buy a dedicated MP3 player today with the software polish and quality of life that an iPod had in the early 2000s”

    Comment from 23 Jan 2026 in “Tech Is Fun Again: The Tech Monoculture Is Finally Breaking”

    “Part of the appeal of the iPod is that it only had just as much hardware and software as it needed and was simple”

    Comment from 23 Oct 2026 in “Apple Music 404 Not Found”

    “Except for the constant glitching and crashing, the iPod had a really great user interface.”

    Comment from 15 Dec 2025 in “Ask HN: What Are You Working On? (December 2025)”
  • Iconic click wheel

    “The click wheel hardware and software implementation (especially the UI response time) was (and still is) revolutionary.”

    Comment from 26 May 2026 in “Dropbox CEO Drew Houston to step down”

    “It was amazing, and I remember the surprise I had when it would make that little piezo click on scroll.”

    Comment from 24 Oct 2026 in “Apple Music 404 Not Found”

    “Holding down the Play/Pause button is not discoverable at all but once you knew it was perfect.”

    Comment from 23 Oct 2026 in “Apple Music 404 Not Found”
  • Still works decades later

    “they are still a damn good mp3 player, especially when you swap in a brand new battery and a gigantic-capacity SD card”

    Comment from 9 Dec 2025 in “Modern Walkmans”

    “The only Apple products that I can think of that haven't degraded in quality over time are the iPods”

    Comment from 25 Aug 2026 in “Apple introduces M6 and M5 Ultra”

    “my 2nd gen iPod still holds a charge and has all the MP3's I've ripped from my cds”

    Comment from 18 Aug 2026 in “Consumers Prefer AI Music Until They're Told It's AI”
  • Offline, keep your own music

    “The original iPod was an offline device with high quality interfaces and it "just worked."”

    Comment from 24 Jul 2026 in “Why Sony Can't Bring Back Its Classic Walkman Models”

    “With iPods you save hundreds of dollars per year, and you get to keep your music”

    Comment from 17 Jul 2026 in “CD Sales Growth Outpaced Vinyl in the First Half of 2026”

What people warn about

Each mark is one comment

  • Clunky iTunes-dependent syncing

    “Syncing and creating playlists with other players was usually awful, slow, and the bundled software was not much better.”

    Comment from 9 Nov 2025 in “Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line”

    “The iPod aren't supported anymore, they require iTunes which is no longer available on macOS.”

    Comment from 1 Oct 2026 in “Sudo – A dedicated music player designed around listening to music”

    “No simple drag and drop onto a mounted USB drive like all other mp3 players back in the day.”

    Comment from 25 Mar 2026 in “Apple Just Lost Me”
  • Glitches and unreliable hard drive

    “Except for the constant glitching and crashing, the iPod had a really great user interface.”

    Comment from 15 Dec 2025 in “Ask HN: What Are You Working On? (December 2025)”

    “it was easily the least-reliable Apple product I ever owned due to that internal 1.8" HDD”

    Comment from 23 Oct 2026 in “Apple Music 404 Not Found”

Other portable music players people recommend

The four most recommended other portable music players, with the same counts for each, so you can compare like for like. The tick on each bar marks the 2 to 1 line the badge needs.

Apple iPod compared with 4 alternatives
ProductRecommendCriticizeApprovalMonthsOwnedBadge
Apple iPodThis page1023276%126 yrs6 ownersApproved
Sony MiniDisc player401277%7—Approved
Sony Walkman202050%6——
Apple iPod Classic18578%8—Approved
Apple iPod nano15194%7—Approved
See all 11 portable music players, ranked

What people said

40 of the 147 comments that mention it, newest first. Each links to the original comment.

“It was amazing, and I remember the surprise I had when it would make that little piezo click on scroll.”

MixedComment from 24 Oct 2026 in “Apple Music 404 Not Found”

“Holding down the Play/Pause button is not discoverable at all but once you knew it was perfect.”

MixedComment from 23 Oct 2026 in “Apple Music 404 Not Found”

“it was easily the least-reliable Apple product I ever owned due to that internal 1.8" HDD”

CriticizesComment from 23 Oct 2026 in “Apple Music 404 Not Found”

“Part of the appeal of the iPod is that it only had just as much hardware and software as it needed and was simple”

RecommendsComment from 23 Oct 2026 in “Apple Music 404 Not Found”

“I use at least one of them almost every day, and sync them with my Macs monthly.”

RecommendsComment from 1 Oct 2026 in “Sudo – A dedicated music player designed around listening to music”

“The iPod aren't supported anymore, they require iTunes which is no longer available on macOS.”

CriticizesComment from 1 Oct 2026 in “Sudo – A dedicated music player designed around listening to music”

“These unforunately are missing the iconic click wheel in favor of a tiny touch screen. The 7th gen even has Bluetooth 4.0.”

MixedComment from 27 Sep 2026 in “16GB iPod Nano 3G Upgrade”

“These unforunately are missing the iconic click wheel in favor of a tiny touch screen”

MixedComment from 27 Sep 2026 in “16GB iPod Nano 3G Upgrade”

“Apple's magic was always the mixture of the two Steves. Technical but stylish.”

RecommendsComment from 23 Sep 2026 in “Apple has added persistent 'ads' to iOS, and it's driving users crazy”

“People will spend more on a Mac or an iPod because it's better than the competition.”

RecommendsComment from 13 Sep 2026 in “Making Startups Powerful”

“Slashdot's review of the iPod was "No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame."”

MixedComment from 10 Sep 2026 in “Coyote v. Acme (1990)”

“The iPod was the first MP3 player to incorporate the then brand new 1.8" Toshiba hard drives”

RecommendsComment from 9 Sep 2026 in “iPhone Duo”

“they normally show up with the version 3 that everyone else wished they'd thought of”

RecommendsComment from 4 Sep 2026 in “IBM Bob”

“the overall experience of the iPod was actually somewhat sub par because of the overuse of that one feature”

MixedComment from 26 Aug 2026 in “Apple introduces M6 and M5 Ultra”

“The only Apple products that I can think of that haven't degraded in quality over time are the iPods”

RecommendsComment from 25 Aug 2026 in “Apple introduces M6 and M5 Ultra”

“I did the same when I tried to copy a friends music from his iPod to my iTunes library.”

MixedComment from 25 Aug 2026 in “Apple introduces M6 and M5 Ultra”

“The iPod's click wheel was amazing. Grab one if you have the chance and play a bit with it.”

RecommendsComment from 25 Aug 2026 in “Apple introduces M6 and M5 Ultra”

“iPods and AirPort Express units from 20+ years ago still work in modern macOS too.”

RecommendsComment from 22 Aug 2026 in “hdiutil is deprecated in macOS 27 Golden Gate”

“my 2nd gen iPod still holds a charge and has all the MP3's I've ripped from my cds”

RecommendsComment from 18 Aug 2026 in “Consumers Prefer AI Music Until They're Told It's AI”

“The 2005 iPod was state of the art and you couldn't buy a memory card for it.”

MixedComment from 25 Jul 2026 in “Why Sony Can't Bring Back Its Classic Walkman Models”

“The iPod was definitely known for a high quality DAC+amp, but do we know what's inside each older or budget Android device?”

MixedComment from 24 Jul 2026 in “Why Sony Can't Bring Back Its Classic Walkman Models”

“the main limiting factor for how much music you can keep on an iPod is the number of songs”

MixedComment from 24 Jul 2026 in “Why Sony Can't Bring Back Its Classic Walkman Models”

“The original iPod was an offline device with high quality interfaces and it "just worked."”

RecommendsComment from 24 Jul 2026 in “Why Sony Can't Bring Back Its Classic Walkman Models”

“The older ipods had a slider switch that disables all buttons and screen inputs, which was awesome”

RecommendsComment from 24 Jul 2026 in “Why Sony Can't Bring Back Its Classic Walkman Models”

“Jobs made sure the iPhone and before it the iPod and before it the iMac were products worth wanting”

RecommendsComment from 17 Jul 2026 in “Starlink 2X Price Increase”

“With iPods you save hundreds of dollars per year, and you get to keep your music”

RecommendsComment from 17 Jul 2026 in “CD Sales Growth Outpaced Vinyl in the First Half of 2026”

“his era at Apple produced exceptional products that redefined their categories”

RecommendsComment from 16 Jun 2026 in “What the Fuck Happened to Nerds”

“The click wheel hardware and software implementation (especially the UI response time) was (and still is) revolutionary.”

RecommendsComment from 26 May 2026 in “Dropbox CEO Drew Houston to step down”

“It's so nice to sit in a chair, close my eyes, and listen to a soundtrack or an old album.”

RecommendsComment from 23 May 2026 in “It's time to talk about my writerdeck”

“Not every blog post needs to be Jony Ive waxing on about the purity of the iPod”

MixedComment from 12 May 2026 in “Why Everyone's Picking Up a PSP Again in 2026”

“Apple has done a much better job at maintaining their stuff compared to Google”

RecommendsComment from 11 May 2026 in “Killed by Apple”

“No simple drag and drop onto a mounted USB drive like all other mp3 players back in the day.”

CriticizesComment from 25 Mar 2026 in “Apple Just Lost Me”

“used iPods for budget-conscious groups that are also looking to make a fashion statement”

MixedComment from 24 Jan 2026 in “Tech Is Fun Again: The Tech Monoculture Is Finally Breaking”

“You cannot buy a dedicated MP3 player today with the software polish and quality of life that an iPod had in the early 2000s”

MixedComment from 23 Jan 2026 in “Tech Is Fun Again: The Tech Monoculture Is Finally Breaking”

“the software polish and quality of life that an iPod had in the early 2000s”

RecommendsComment from 23 Jan 2026 in “Tech Is Fun Again: The Tech Monoculture Is Finally Breaking”

“The iPod was very innovative (first time you could have all your music with you on the go”

RecommendsComment from 19 Dec 2025 in “2026 Apple introducing more ads to increase opportunity in search results”

“Except for the constant glitching and crashing, the iPod had a really great user interface.”

MixedComment from 15 Dec 2025 in “Ask HN: What Are You Working On? (December 2025)”

“they are still a damn good mp3 player, especially when you swap in a brand new battery and a gigantic-capacity SD card”

RecommendsComment from 9 Dec 2025 in “Modern Walkmans”

“Syncing and creating playlists with other players was usually awful, slow, and the bundled software was not much better.”

MixedComment from 9 Nov 2025 in “Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line”

“it was better than the competition simply because Apple had access to better hardware”

RecommendsComment from 7 Nov 2025 in “Apple is crossing a Steve Jobs red line”

Counts come from 1,795,640 Hacker News comments, November 2025 to November 2026. How we count. Report a mistake.