Hacker ApprovedDepartments

Bandcamp

Hacker Approved

The most recommended of 3 music stores

People buy music on Bandcamp to pay artists directly and get DRM-free, high-quality downloads, though many find its search, app and recommendations poor.

People buy music on Bandcamp to pay artists directly and get DRM-free, high-quality downloads, though many find its search, app and recommendations poor.

149 people gave an opinion

recommend it
132
criticize it
17
approval share
89%
Each figure is one person. RecommendsCriticizes

Recommended in 13 of 13 months

  1. November 2025: recommended
  2. December 2025: recommended
  3. January 2026: recommended
  4. February 2026: recommended
  5. March 2026: recommended
  6. April 2026: recommended
  7. May 2026: recommended
  8. June 2026: recommended
  9. July 2026: recommended
  10. August 2026: recommended
  11. September 2026: recommended
  12. October 2026: recommended
  13. November 2026: recommended (month in progress)

Owned for 10 years

Median of the 3 owners who said how long they have had it.

Each square is one year.

Why it carries the badge

  • 132 people recommend itNeeds 10 or more, met.
  • 7.8 recommenders for every criticNeeds 2 to 1 or better, met.
  • Recommended in 13 of 13 monthsNeeds 4 or more, met.

The same three rules apply to every product, and the badge can’t be bought. How the badge works

What people say about it

The reasons people give, with the number of comments that give each one. Open a reason to read what they said.

Why people recommend it

Each mark is one comment

  • Money goes directly to artists

    “Bandcamp makes money from people who consciously avoided the streaming shitfest in favor of directly supporting the artists”

    Comment from 13 Jan 2026 in “AI Generated Music Barred from Bandcamp”

    “Yeah or even better I buy the album on Bandcamp, then they get either 85% of the price, or 100% on "Bandcamp Friday".”

    Comment from 8 Jan 2026 on Hacker News

    “I made 90 Euros on Bandcamp in December and 0.08 Eurocent on all other streaming platforms together!”

    Comment from 14 Jan 2026 in “AI Generated Music Barred from Bandcamp”
  • DRM-free high-quality FLAC downloads

    “Albums are usually ~$10 for high-fidelity digital downloads, and ~$25 gets you a vinyl record + the digital download.”

    Comment from 28 May 2026 in “DuckDuckGo search saw 28% more visits after Google said people love AI mode”

    “It's delightful to be able to just listen to something then hand the artist money and download the flac files.”

    Comment from 29 Jun 2026 in “Tidal AI Policy”

    “the process of buying high-quality, DRM-free MP3 music is as simple and straightforward as it can be”

    Comment from 21 Dec 2025 in “Backing up Spotify”
  • Free listening before buying

    “I went to her Bandcamp page and was able to listen to some tracks for free with zero friction.”

    Comment from 16 Jul 2026 in “As a musician, I prefer illegal downloading over Spotify (2011)”

    “i can usually find it on bandcamp or youtube without having to pay for a stream or two”

    Comment from 22 May 2026 in “If you're an LLM, please read this – Anna's Blog”

    “Mostly I listen to new albums on Bandcamp, and if I like them enough, I buy them.”

    Comment from 6 Jan 2026 in “How Spotify Made Me Self Host”
  • Genre browsing and curated discovery

    “their trending charts which seem to be unpopular enough that it's not entirely controlled by marketing”

    Comment from 17 Apr 2026 in “Everything we like is a psyop”

    “I wander around bandcamp and find stuff that isn't heavy metal, but enjoyable, so I buy it.”

    Comment from 9 Jul 2026 in “A new way to reflect on how you use Claude”

    “It's artist focused and they have shows with DJs that focus on highlighting new releases.”

    Comment from 22 Jul 2026 in “It's a shame what's happened to radio”

What people warn about

Each mark is one comment

  • Weak discovery and recommendations

    “I absolutely don't agree that Bandcamp does recommendations well. To me, it seems like they don't personalize at all.”

    Comment from 14 Jan 2026 in “AI Generated Music Barred from Bandcamp”

    “that is better than the front page, but still it takes a lot of effort”

    Comment from 14 Jan 2026 in “AI Generated Music Barred from Bandcamp”

    “Discoverability and usability in general is godawful on bandcamp.”

    Comment from 16 Jul 2026 in “The lost joy of music piracy”
  • Clunky search, app and site

    “The app and site are awful, and even finding stuff you've bought to play or download can be a nightmare”

    Comment from 17 Jul 2026 in “The lost joy of music piracy”

    “It's often completely impossible to find an artist or album or song even when you type the exact name.”

    Comment from 26 Aug 2026 in “RAG Is Simpler Than You Think”

    “the free/preview player doesn't have a volume control but the library player does”

    Comment from 21 Mar 2026 in “The worst volume control UI in the world”
  • Worries since Epic, Songtradr sales

    “have slowly felt more and more uncomfortable with it ever since the initial Epic acquisition”

    Comment from 30 Jun 2026 in “Bandcamp has laid off most of their engineers”

    “bandcamp laid off virtually all of their engineers a month or so back”

    Comment from 1 Sep 2026 in “Fastpotify”

    “I'm still sad about the company's sale to Epic and then Songtradr”

    Comment from 14 Jan 2026 in “AI Generated Music Barred from Bandcamp”
  • Not all music available there

    “I wish more musicians were on Bandcamp, and more authors sold e-books directly from their website.”

    Comment from 28 Jun 2026 in “PlayStation Is Deleting 551 Movies from Customers' Accounts”

    “I buy everything on Bandcamp... when it's available there, which is increasingly not the case.”

    Comment from 4 Nov 2025 on Hacker News

Other music stores people recommend

The two most recommended other music stores, with the same counts for each, so you can compare like for like. The tick on each bar marks the 2 to 1 line the badge needs.

Bandcamp compared with 2 alternatives
ProductRecommendCriticizeApprovalMonthsOwnedBadge
BandcampThis page1321789%1310 yrs3 ownersApproved
iTunes Store181555%7——
7digital80100%6——
See all 3 music stores, ranked

What people said

40 of the 181 comments that mention it, newest first. Each links to the original comment.

“I enjoy Bandcamp, but I'm going to have to axe it if it keeps up.”

MixedComment from 8 Sep 2026 in “Ask HN: Are others seeing Google's reCAPTCHA rejecting Firefox users?”

“bandcamp laid off virtually all of their engineers a month or so back”

CriticizesComment from 1 Sep 2026 in “Fastpotify”

“It's often completely impossible to find an artist or album or song even when you type the exact name.”

CriticizesComment from 26 Aug 2026 in “RAG Is Simpler Than You Think”

“knowing that the music creators are getting a larger cut than Spotify would ever give them”

RecommendsComment from 4 Aug 2026 in “Spotify just hit 300M Premium subscribers”

“It's artist focused and they have shows with DJs that focus on highlighting new releases.”

RecommendsComment from 22 Jul 2026 in “It's a shame what's happened to radio”

“The app and site are awful, and even finding stuff you've bought to play or download can be a nightmare”

CriticizesComment from 17 Jul 2026 in “The lost joy of music piracy”

“I went to her Bandcamp page and was able to listen to some tracks for free with zero friction.”

RecommendsComment from 16 Jul 2026 in “As a musician, I prefer illegal downloading over Spotify (2011)”

“Bandcamp is indeed really bad at suggesting things you’ll like”

CriticizesComment from 16 Jul 2026 in “The lost joy of music piracy”

“Discoverability and usability in general is godawful on bandcamp.”

CriticizesComment from 16 Jul 2026 in “The lost joy of music piracy”

“I wander around bandcamp and find stuff that isn't heavy metal, but enjoyable, so I buy it.”

RecommendsComment from 9 Jul 2026 in “A new way to reflect on how you use Claude”

“BC is probably the best platform for people who care to pay and support acts directly”

RecommendsComment from 2 Jul 2026 in “24-bit/192kHz music downloads and why they make no sense”

“have slowly felt more and more uncomfortable with it ever since the initial Epic acquisition”

CriticizesComment from 30 Jun 2026 in “Bandcamp has laid off most of their engineers”

“It's delightful to be able to just listen to something then hand the artist money and download the flac files.”

RecommendsComment from 29 Jun 2026 in “Tidal AI Policy”

“If you want to support actual musicians, you can just buy their music directly.”

RecommendsComment from 29 Jun 2026 in “Tidal AI Policy”

“I wish more musicians were on Bandcamp, and more authors sold e-books directly from their website.”

RecommendsComment from 28 Jun 2026 in “PlayStation Is Deleting 551 Movies from Customers' Accounts”

“Albums are usually ~$10 for high-fidelity digital downloads, and ~$25 gets you a vinyl record + the digital download.”

RecommendsComment from 28 May 2026 in “DuckDuckGo search saw 28% more visits after Google said people love AI mode”

“has already demonstrated good will with the community steps up and builds something that would be a delight”

RecommendsComment from 25 May 2026 in “Show HN: Audiomass – a free, open-source multitrack audio editor for the web”

“i can usually find it on bandcamp or youtube without having to pay for a stream or two”

RecommendsComment from 22 May 2026 in “If you're an LLM, please read this – Anna's Blog”

“having access to it whenever I want is entirely effortless and doesn't require anything beyond Bandcamp itself”

RecommendsComment from 21 May 2026 in “Spotify Will Start Reserving Concert Tickets for Fans”

“It should be more like how Bandcamp pays artists (80% to the artists, 20% for Bandcamp)”

RecommendsComment from 23 Apr 2026 in “Ars Technica: Our newsroom AI policy”

“If you actually want to support specific artists, you'd have to use Bandcamp or similar sites.”

RecommendsComment from 23 Apr 2026 in “Ars Technica: Our newsroom AI policy”

“their trending charts which seem to be unpopular enough that it's not entirely controlled by marketing”

RecommendsComment from 17 Apr 2026 in “Everything we like is a psyop”

“the free/preview player doesn't have a volume control but the library player does”

CriticizesComment from 21 Mar 2026 in “The worst volume control UI in the world”

“Tend to use Bandcamp mostly, they also waive their fee on purchases every first Friday of the month”

RecommendsComment from 18 Mar 2026 in “Spotify playing ads for paid subscribers”

“you can select the genre and a sorting criteria and have very good control over the list”

RecommendsComment from 17 Mar 2026 in “Meta and TikTok let harmful content rise to drove engagement, say whistleblowers”

“Bandcamp has given them more ability to make money off the actual sale of music”

RecommendsComment from 23 Jan 2026 in “Qwen3-TTS Family Is Now Open Sourced: Voice Design, Clone, and Generation”

“that is better than the front page, but still it takes a lot of effort”

MixedComment from 14 Jan 2026 in “AI Generated Music Barred from Bandcamp”

“I absolutely don't agree that Bandcamp does recommendations well. To me, it seems like they don't personalize at all.”

CriticizesComment from 14 Jan 2026 in “AI Generated Music Barred from Bandcamp”

“I made 90 Euros on Bandcamp in December and 0.08 Eurocent on all other streaming platforms together!”

RecommendsComment from 14 Jan 2026 in “AI Generated Music Barred from Bandcamp”

“I'm still sad about the company's sale to Epic and then Songtradr”

MixedComment from 14 Jan 2026 in “AI Generated Music Barred from Bandcamp”

“Bandcamp makes money from people who consciously avoided the streaming shitfest in favor of directly supporting the artists”

RecommendsComment from 13 Jan 2026 in “AI Generated Music Barred from Bandcamp”

“Yeah or even better I buy the album on Bandcamp, then they get either 85% of the price, or 100% on "Bandcamp Friday".”

RecommendsComment from 8 Jan 2026 on Hacker News

“Mostly I listen to new albums on Bandcamp, and if I like them enough, I buy them.”

RecommendsComment from 6 Jan 2026 in “How Spotify Made Me Self Host”

“the process of buying high-quality, DRM-free MP3 music is as simple and straightforward as it can be”

RecommendsComment from 21 Dec 2025 in “Backing up Spotify”

“Really the only place where you can sell HQ audio on your own and that has an audience”

RecommendsComment from 9 Dec 2025 in “Modern Walkmans”

“I'll send you a real physical tape and you can _download_ high quality FLAC you own then.”

RecommendsComment from 12 Nov 2025 in “You will own nothing and be (un)happy”

“moving out of the universe of royalty-based revenue is a huge step in the right direction”

RecommendsComment from 5 Nov 2025 on Hacker News

“I agree that Bandcamp falls short in some of the social dimensions that it feels like it should do better at.”

MixedComment from 4 Nov 2025 on Hacker News

“I buy everything on Bandcamp... when it's available there, which is increasingly not the case.”

MixedComment from 4 Nov 2025 on Hacker News

“the feeling you get from directly supporting an artist when you purchase from Bandcamp.”

RecommendsComment from 4 Nov 2025 on Hacker News

Counts come from 1,795,640 Hacker News comments, November 2025 to November 2026. How we count. Report a mistake.